2 Types of Gutter Guards Compared
Types of gutter guards include micro-mesh systems; this comparison covers ArmourGuard and Gutter Guard by Gutterglove. ArmourGuard is an extruded metal micro-mesh gutter guard system intended to keep leaves and debris out when installed under shingles. Gutter Guard by Gutterglove is a stainless steel micro-mesh guard intended for homes prone to wildlife activity or pine needles. Both options use micro-mesh, but their construction, installation details, and stated use differ.
3 years of local experience
Get a Free Estimate| Name | Gutter guard type | Stated intended use | Installation approach | Debris detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ArmourGuard | Extruded metal micro-mesh | Leaves and debris; installed under shingles | Within the gutter; best with an extension piece under shingles | Some pine needles entered the screen in testing |
| Gutter Guard by Gutterglove | Stainless steel micro-mesh | Wildlife activity or pine needles; mature trees and regular rainfall | Measure, clean, cut, and secure with included screws | Leaves, pine needles, pests, and fine roof grit |
1. ArmourGuard
ArmourGuard uses an extruded metal micro-mesh design. Gutter Guards Direct says it is a micro-mesh system designed to install within the gutter, and its test installation used a five inch panel in a six inch gutter. The system performed best with an extension piece under the first course of shingles, which makes the roof-edge installation detail important for homeowners comparing compatibility. Gutter Guards Direct says ArmourGuard was more porous than the GutterDome system, and some pine needles entered the screen. The same seller reports a negligible amount of debris remaining on the cover. ArmourGuard is available in a number of states from All American Gutter Protection.
ArmourGuard is intended for keeping leaves and debris out when installed under shingles.
Key facts
- ArmourGuard was installed as a five inch panel in a six inch gutter during the test (according to Gutter Guards Direct).
Pros:
- The extruded metal construction gives the guard a defined metal system design.
- The cover had a negligible amount of debris remaining in the stated test.
- Website: https://www.gutterguardsdirect.com/ultimate-gutter-guard-challenge/armourguard/
2. Gutter Guard by Gutterglove
Gutter Guard by Gutterglove is a stainless steel micro-mesh guard with extruded aluminum rails. Gutter Guard by Gutterglove says its micro-mesh technology filters and blocks leaves, pine needles, pests, and fine roof grit while allowing water filtration. The brand also says V-Bend and Trough Technology adds strength and rigidity, improves filtration, helps prevent debris buildup, and supports water flow. The brand says the stainless steel micro-mesh keeps out the finest debris. Installation involves measuring, cleaning, cutting, and securing the guards to the gutters with the included screws. The guard is intended for homes prone to wildlife activity or pine needles, homes surrounded by large mature trees, and homes that receive regular rainfall. Product registration includes a complimentary maintenance brush, excluding shipping and handling.
Gutter Guard by Gutterglove is intended for homes prone to wildlife activity or pine needles, mature trees, and regular rainfall.
Pros:
- The micro-mesh design is intended to address leaves, pine needles, pests, and fine roof grit.
- The included installation steps and screws give homeowners a defined process for securing the guards to the gutters.
- Website: https://gutterguard.com/stainless-steel-micro-mesh-gutter-guards/
How to Choose Types of Gutter Guards
FAQ
What types of gutter guards are ArmourGuard and Gutter Guard by Gutterglove?
ArmourGuard is an extruded metal micro-mesh gutter guard system. Gutter Guard by Gutterglove is a stainless steel micro-mesh gutter guard with extruded aluminum rails. Both are micro-mesh options, but they use different stated materials and construction details.
Which gutter guard handles pine needles and fine debris?
Gutter Guard by Gutterglove is intended for homes prone to wildlife activity or pine needles, and the brand says its micro-mesh filters leaves, pine needles, pests, and fine roof grit. ArmourGuard is intended to keep leaves and debris out when installed under shingles, but Gutter Guards Direct says some pine needles got inside its screen during the comparison with the GutterDome system.
How is ArmourGuard installed under shingles?
ArmourGuard is designed to install within the gutter. Its stated best installation used an extension piece under the first course of shingles, so the roof edge and existing gutter arrangement should be checked before installation.
How do you install Gutter Guard by Gutterglove?
The stated process is to measure, clean, cut, and secure the guards to the gutters using the included screws. This gives the homeowner a defined installation sequence, but compatibility with the existing gutter and roof-edge setup still needs to be confirmed.
Do gutter guards still need cleaning after installation?
Yes. Gutter guards can still collect debris on their surface, especially during heavy leaf fall or after storms, and fine particles can enter or form hidden clogs. Micro-mesh guards may need regular surface cleaning or occasional rinsing to keep water moving through the system.
Can gutter guards correct drainage problems?
No stored product detail establishes that either option corrects an existing drainage defect. Gutter guards cannot correct undersized gutters, missing downspouts, sagging gutters, poor pitch, or drainage problems, so those conditions should be evaluated separately before installation.
When should a homeowner use professional gutter guard installation?
Professional installation is relevant when the system requires professional work or when the homeowner cannot safely verify the roof edge, gutter condition, and drainage setup. Incorrect DIY installation can void a roof or gutter warranty and cause drainage problems, while fasteners that penetrate shingles can affect roof coverage.
Are gutter guards worth buying instead of continuing gutter cleaning?
The decision depends on the debris load, access to the gutters, installation cost, and maintenance that will remain afterward. Guards can reduce cleaning and prevent many common blockages, but they still require inspection and maintenance; they may be less of a priority where gutters are easy to clear safely or the environment is relatively leaf-free.
Next Steps
Ask the seller or a gutter guard installation professional whether the selected system matches the existing gutter size, roof edge, shingles, pitch, downspouts, and drainage setup. For ArmourGuard, confirm whether an extension piece is needed under the first course of shingles. For Gutter Guard by Gutterglove, confirm the rail and screw installation requirements and whether the included brush applies after product registration, excluding shipping and handling. Request a quote that separates installation from any gutter repairs or drainage corrections, and ask what inspection and cleaning will still be required after installation. If DIY work could affect a roof or gutter warranty, consult a gutter guard installation professional before proceeding.
Last updated October 2026
